March 15, 2024
Veteran defense and security reporter Ponomarenko was just settling into the new media venture he cofounded, the Kyiv Independent, when Russia started making unreasonable demands on his home country of Ukraine and then invaded, starting the biggest war in Europe since 1945. Ponomarenko brings to life in vivid detail what it was like on the ground before, during, and after the Russian onslaught on the capital city. Sprinkling American pop culture references (hat tip to the many Lord of the Rings quips) throughout the narrative, the author does precisely what the title states, making the reader feel the fear, uncertainty, and danger that the fog of war forces regular people to endure. Ponomarenko stands defiant in his tours of the front line and all that he witnessed, rhetorically spitting in the face of Russian aggression. The war in Ukraine is far from over, but this book faithfully covers the first half of 2022 and the tentative victory of the underdogs in Kyiv. Ponomarenko remains optimistic that Ukraine will resist until the end.
COPYRIGHT(2024) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from February 15, 2024
A remarkable on-the-ground report from the Battle of Kyiv in 2022. War reporting is perhaps the most difficult branch of journalism. It is easy to be overwhelmed by the sheer drama: the blood and the thunder, the sense of history being written, the images and the noise. Ponomarenko, a Ukrainian journalist and co-founder of an online newspaper called the Kyiv Independent, makes no attempt to be impartial in his account of the roughly six-week battle for Kyiv, a city that he loved. "We were just moments away," he writes, "from bidding farewell to our home and our way of life." He kept posting his reports during and after the battle, describing the invasion as "one of the most tragic--and the most bizarre--events in modern history," serving as "the opening act of the biggest European bloodbath since 1945, and one of the most shamelessly trumped-up, absurd, and unnecessary wars the world had ever seen." The author mixes in pieces of the increasingly unbelievable statements from the Russian government, with Putin claiming victory even as his tanks were reduced to smoking wrecks. Ponomarenko notes that it was often hard to see through the fog of war, but the Russian attacks on the city's civilian precincts told their own stories. In fact, the slaughter of innocents merely hardened the resolve of the Ukrainian population to endure and fight. The author ends with the Russians retreating to their strongholds in the east. While he believes that Ukrainian forces will eventually prevail, the cost is massive. The book lives up to its title, with countless pages that are alternately heart-rending, stomach-churning, and even inspiring. This is an important story, and Ponomarenko tells it with passion and intelligence. A revelatory portrait of the horror and absurdity of the conflict spiked with much-needed threads of humanity and hope.
COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.